
I, Derek Leif, loathe "Mr. Holland's Opus."
There it is.
Look, I just can't improve on that: I loathe this movie. I loathe everything it is.
This will require multiple essays.
The depth of my loathing of the film "Mr. Holland's Opus" may require a separate blog.
Let's just dive in, and get the gist:
Richard Dreyfuss plays a music teacher in which teaching drains the life blood out of him. God, how the process of teaching crushes this man. He slowly settles for teaching music, raising his deaf son in the process.
Yes, I said deaf son.
Get it? HE HAS A DEAF SON AND HE'S A COMPOSER.
Let's just see if maybe we've got the irony, Wait, let me get a bigger font, as this film subtly says:
Do you get it? Do you get it? HE IS A MUSIC TEACHER WHO SACRIFICED COMPOSING SO AS TO RAISE A DEAF CHILD. THIS CHILD (WHO IS DEAF) WILL, BEING DEAF, NEVER HEAR HIS MUSIC BECAUSE HE IS DEAF! CAN YOU HEAR ME ABOVE THIS CHANTING? CAN YOU HEAR ME? Hmmm..wait...we're segueing into an "Altered States" reference, in which William Hurt is in the isolation tank after...
...oy, middle school librarian rule. Must stop here. Let's get back to Mr. Holland, shall we?
Anyway, suffice to say that the film assumes that we are as deaf to noticing irony as Mr. Holland's son is to hearing his music.
(And by the way, wouldn't it be far more devastating if his son was actually far more talented than he was, and studied with Evelyn Glennie, and became a renowned composer? Wouldn't it be powerful if the son felt the sides of the piano as his father played his Opus, and then signed "Dad, I hate to say this, but it really isn't that good.")
(And by the way of By the Way, Evelyn Glennie is just so cool. I mean, just watch this TED speech she gave about hearing with her body to overcome her profound hearing loss.)
Anyway, the film. Yes. Forgive me. I have to take refuge in people such as Evelyn Glennie when writing about Mr. Holland. Sorry.
Resuming where we left off...
(Oh, wait, I didn't finish the digression about how great the film would be if Mr. Holland's son were a deaf musical genius. Wouldn't it be great if the deaf son, having been trained in music and percussion by Evelyn Glennie, now turned dad's awful Opus into something amazing, just like Mozart did with Salieri in Amadeus? And wouldn't it be great if Dad cursed God in front of the fireplace and vowed that he would drive his son to an early death by hiring his son to write a requiem that would cause the son to die young? Then Richard Dreyfus could say "I will destroy your creation, God, and your creation won't hear a thing. Because he's deaf. I'm a composer, and my son is deaf. I've always found that ironic, my son being deaf and all.")
(Then, in my version, Mr. Holland's Opus would be the requiem mass that the school orchestra would play at his son's funeral. Except Mr. Holland would say that he wrote it. Yeah. Yeah.)
(End of digression.)
Anyway, as he's trying to get his son, who is deaf, to appreciate his music through lights, he falls for the high-school-senior girl who gets the lead in a Gershwin review. Her name is Rowena Morgan. He composes music for her.
From there, it gets worse. As this subplot thickens, Dreyfus's Holland feels like he might be one of Matthew Brodericks's friends from the film Election.
Consequently, I cannot watch these scenes without thinking of Bill Hicks, and for the sake of my job, I will not provide the necessary links to Goat Boy monologues. I just won't.
But should you be a Bill Hicks fan, I ask that, now that I've put that thought in your head, feel free to do the Bill Hicks "Goat Boy" laugh whenever Jean Louisa Kelly, who plays Rowena Morgan, is on the screen.
After this sequence, we watch Dreyfus age at an alarming rate, as teaching grinds him down, and sucks out his soul. It is great age makeup, and it reminds me of Kevin McCarthy's transformation in the Twilight Zone episode "Long Live Walter Jamison."
Eventually, at age 60, Holland/Dreyfus gets canned, and shuffles around like a man twice that age, taking deep, wheezing gasps with each footstep.
"What will I do now," he says, having taught for hundreds of years by now.
Well, I thought, you could retire, travel, and maybe, who knows, compose music. Maybe he could do the Frank McCourt thing. Second Act, you know?
I mean, the guy who said there were no second acts was dead by the time he was 40, and his wife was crazy. So maybe F. Scott Fitzgerald was wrong.
I should know. I live down the block from the house where he wrote The Great Gatsby. That means I'm right. It's a kind of Fox News logic that you just have to go along with. Please do so.
Anyway, no. Dreyfuss shuffles and wheezes off, presumably onto an ice floe, where he will float away like an elderly Inuit, fall into the water, and die.
But no. He goes into the auditorium, and all his students from years past play the music he's been composing for thirty years.
It is five minutes of music.
The End.
This is just...it is just horrible. I need a break. I'll write more about this, particularly when I have nothing else to write about. I promise.
God, I hate this film.
P.S. The folks who moved into the Gatsby house completely renovated it, and took out the greenhouse where Fitzgerald is said to have written the book. Persians love turning houses into boxes. It's boxy now.